The following contains spoilers for Episode 6 ofSurvivorSeason 41.
It’s the moment where the game truly starts. It’s been days and days of trying to survive on a tropical island and find the balance between securing an alliance and furthering your personal game. This is when the individual portion of the game begins - no more tribe immunity, only that much-coveted immunity necklace that’s one of the few guarantees of safety at Tribal Council. Jeff Probst declares, “Drop your buffs”, and suddenly the three tribes become one. It’s the Merge, and Season 41 ofSurvivorhas finally reached it…sort of.
While it’s true that Episode 6 was the long-awaited Merge episode, only about half of the tribe got to truly celebrate a Merge. This season ofSurvivorhas been determined to beas different from past ones as possible, and this Merge was certainly distinctive. For starters, this is a two-part episode with no elimination, which is a very rare occurrence inSurvivor. All of the unconventional changes and the choice to end on a cliffhanger make this “Merge” episode feel very strange and different.
RELATED:A Telltale-Style ‘Survivor’ Game Makes A Lot of Sense
The episode begins with scenes of Shan and Ricard arguing once again over Shan’s extra vote advantage that Ricard is holding onto. Shan feels that it’s shady of Ricard to refuse to give the advantage back when that’s what they agreed to (and it’s not even his to begin with), and he likewise feels that it’s suspicious of her to ask for the advantage back as though she doesn’t trust him. This might be sowing the seeds for a future storyline that will happen where Shan and Ricard recognize the threat that the other poses to them and try to get each other out.
In general, it seems likeShan’s choice to keep Ricard over Geniemight come back to bite her, because Ricard seems much more untrustworthy and likely to turn on Shan, so it’s really baffling as to why she chose that alliance to go into the Merge with. The fact that Ricard was being very protective of an advantage that wasn’t even his should be setting off some red flags for Shan.
Finally, it’s time for the tribes to enter the game area where they will be (somewhat) Merged. But first, Jeff addresses the audience directly again, explaining the twist before the castaways reach the area. This was a very odd choice, because it spoils the twist of the “Merge” in a very anti-climactic way, since it’s explained to the audience and then immediately after to the players. It was likelyan attempt to bring the viewers into the gamelike they’ve been doing all season, but this one just felt very awkward and made Jeff’s Merge announcement to the castaways fall a little flat.
The rules surrounding this Merge are actually a little confusing. The players are split into two groups to compete in the challenge (except for the players who drew gray rocks, who sit the challenge out), and whichever group wins will be officially Merged, getting to partake in the classic Merge Feast and also being immune at Tribal Council. The losing team will have tocompete in the Individual Immunity Challengelater on for a safe spot at Tribal, and won’t get the food (which, after this many days, is probably the part that hurts the most). The winning team will also pick one of the gray-rock players to come with them and be Merged, and the other will be sent to Exile Island to be alone for two days.
In the end, despite a terrific show of perseverance and teamwork from the yellow team, the blue team is victorious, meaning that Danny, Deshawn, Evvie, Ricard, and Sydney are all officially Merged and receive the bright red Merge buff. They choose to take Naseer with them, leaving Erika to be shipped off to Exile Island, which at the very least finally gives her some much-needed screen time. She gets a backstory editing package where she speaks onthe sacrifices her parents madeto give her a good childhood and draws on that to do her best to survive alone on this island.
At the Merge feast, the castaways are getting to know each other, and also enjoying some sustenance that they desperately needed. Evvie mentions that she thinks this is the most difficult season ofSurvivorso far because of the lack of food, which is totally fair but is also something that the show hasn’t been focusing on as much as it should. For all of the marketing thatthis is the toughest season ever, the show has kind of glossed over the struggle that the players have been having with not enough food to eat. In general, the season itself hasn’t exactly been delivering on the marketing of being the “most difficult and dangerous season ever” that the pre-season teased.
Back at the Luvu camp, which is where the Merged tribe will be living, the losing team is getting to know each other while trying not to feel too upset about not officially making the Merge. This sort of weird, in-between stage of the Merge is strange because it’s unclear when the Merge actually happens, and it’s confusing to keep track of. Shan, for some unknown reason,asks Liana about her advantagein front of Tiffany, and Liana is forced to admit that she has one when she wanted to keep it a secret. It becomes clear that despite the deal that the remaining Yase members made to stick together, there is a lot of distrust among them, since Liana and Tiffany don’t fully trust each other.
When the winning team comes back, the strategy talk begins, and it basically consists of everyone agreeing to vote Erika off because she’s the easy vote, as the only one not there. They’re also suspicious that she could come back into the game with an advantage, and they want toget rid of any potential threatas soon as possible. This is also when Shan and Liana extend an invitation to Deshawn and Danny to join them and create an all-Black alliance, prompting a discussion about how diverse this season has been, and it’s nice to seeSurvivoroutwardly address diversity and the experiences of people of color on the show. If there’s one thing Season 41 has done right, it’s the genuine attempt at inclusivity.
Back at Exile Island, Erika is tending to her fire when Jeff Probst rolls up to the island. He brings with him a really interesting twist, and the opportunity for Erika to change everything. He hands her an hourglass and gives her the choice to either leave it alone and keep everything as-is, or to"change history" by smashing it, which would strip the currently Merged castaways of their Merged status and immunity and give it to the losing team (and Erika) instead, essentially flipping the script. This is a crazy amount of power, and leaves Erika in an interesting position. If she smashes it, she’s safe and also getting revenge on the people who sent her to the island in the first place, but it also means she will probably burn bridges with them. Of course, she doesn’t know that these people are planning to vote her out anyways.
The episode ends on a cliffhanger where the audience doesn’t know which choice Erika will make. This is a new tactic forSurvivor, but it kind of makes the episode fall flat. It’s all building up to next week being exciting, but it felt like not a lot happened in this episode in particular because of that. In general, this episode didn’t have the magic that most Merge episodes have because of the convoluted rules. This season has been trying to innovateSurvivorso much that it feels like they’re losingthe magic that made the show greatin the first place. They need to find the balance between freshening up the game while also keeping that classicSurvivorfeeling that has made it endure for all of this time.
