When Todd Howard called Bethesda’s new sci-fi RPGStarfield“Skyrimin space,” it was easy to write the comment off as an appeal to the studio’s greatest hits, glossing over the bumpy recent history of theFalloutfranchise and assuring fans that a more traditional Bethesda RPG with a focus on freedom above all else was on the way. The more that’s revealed about the game, however, the more the structural similarities between the stories of Bethesda’s new IP andSkyrimseem apparent.
Starfield’s main quest, likeSkyrim’s World-Eater plotline, appeals to the existential, promising “humanity’s final journey” and answers to “life’s greatest mystery.” Despite the larger stakes, it’s also apparent that, as inSkyrim, humanity hasn’t lost its appetite for petty conflict. There have been several indications thatStarfield’s secondary plotline, likeSkyrim’s civil war, will involve some surprisingly similar factions duking it out.Skyrim’s civil war questline, however, was far from perfect. Here’s what Bethesda needs to learn before taking to the stars in its next RPG.
RELATED:How Daggerfall’s Dragon Break May Impact The Elder Scrolls 6
The Empire And The Rebels
In mostElder Scrollsgames so far, particularlyOblivion, the Empire of Tamriel is portrayed as sympathetic. Uriel Septim wasn’t just wise and benevolent; he was imbued with the gift of prophecy. Martin Septim sacrificed himself to save Tamriel from Mehrunes Dagon, ending his line in doing so. InSkyrim, the Empire is made more morally ambiguous, but the more players learn the muddier the waters become.
Skyrim’s Empire is on the back foot, recently forced into a harsh treaty by the cackling evil supremacistAldmeri Dominionthat forces them to outlaw Talos worship or risk another war they cannot win. The game’s opening certainly frames the Empire in a bad light, but the game leans on the moral ambiguity of its civil war factions to exhaustion. Arriving in the Stormcloak capital of Windhelm quickly confirms that their fight for independence comes with a xenophobic streak, and there are suggestions that Ulfric’s killing of the High King was far from honorable.
It already seems likeStarfieldwill have two major factions with many similarities to the Empire and the Stormcloaks. In theLocation Insightsvideo on the city ofNew Atlantis, design director Emil Pagliarulo describes the city of New Atlantis as “the capital city of the United Colonies, U.C., the most powerful, established military and political faction in the game. The city is a true melting pot.”
Like theEmpire of Tamriel, the United Colonies is the larger faction, sourcing strength in its diversity. It’s also apparent, however, that its broad reach isn’t entirely popular outside of its hub. In the video on Akila City, Pagliarulo describes the capital of the Freestar Collective, a faction that holds the “sanctity of personal freedom and individuality” above all else.
There’s nothing to suggest thatthe Freestar Collectiveis at war with the United Colonies, but the characterizations of the two factions are very familiar. It also seems likely that their trade-offs – an empire that cannot understand the needs of the people on its fringes, and a splinter group that risks small-mindedness – are similar as well.
The Greater Threat
As with the Empire and theStormcloaks, the failure of these two factions to cooperate appears to have created an opportunity for an unambiguously evil faction to rise to prominence. In an in-universe email seen on Pagliarulo’s computer in theInto the Starfield: The Journey Beginsvideo, a faction named the Crimson Fleet is mentioned.
The message, signed off by UC Fleet Admiral Pascual Logan, explains that “pirates of the Crimson Fleet have extended far beyond the Kryx System […] This is clearly no longer just a Freestar Collective problem.” While little else is known about the faction, ifBethesdawas angling to make the Crimson Fleet morally ambiguous by framing them as freedom-loving freebooters, it seems unlikely that the Freestar Collective would already have been characterized in a similar way. Instead, it’s likely that players will find a faction that matches the Dominion’s brutality, if not its aesthetic.
RELATED:Starfield: The Case for Playable Aliens
Surpassing Skyrim’s Civil War
The dynamic between these three major players strongly resemblesSkyrim’s civil war. Although helping the Dominion wasn’t an option inSkyrim, it seems extremely likely that, as in the civil war questline, players will be able to throw their weight behind a faction of their choice.
The problem is thatSkyrim’s civil war, while a great part of the premise, is far from the game’s greatest strength. Completing the questline sees a few ofSkyrim’s Jarlsreplaced, lets the player take part in a few measly skirmishes, and once the moral ambiguity of both factions is established it isn’t complicated or explored any further.
Starfieldcan’t just beSkyrimin space. The player’s impact on the balance of power in its universe needs to imbue them with a greater sense of agency and a far greater sense of impact. Unlike inSkyrim, players should be able to unite two of the factions against a major threat, even if that’s extremely difficult. There should be major battles that putSkyrim’s measly skirmishes to shame. The potential outcome of this conflict should be more than a binary, and its impact on the game’s world should be more thanSkyrim’s shallow reshuffling of a few NPCs.
Todd Howard’s appeal toSkyrimfans makes sense from a marketing perspective, but the question of whether Bethesda has truly moved on fromThe Elder Scrolls 5and is able to tell more complicated stories and give the player a more meaningful impact on its games’ settings hangs over the studio’s new IP. Howard has also stated thatStarfieldwill be “a bit more hardcore of a role-playing game” than the studio’s last few releases. Hopefully this will see the player’s impact on the game’s major factions eclipse the impact they had inSkyrim. Whether the story those factions will tell can surpass the shortcomings ofSkyrim’s civil war questline remains to be seen, however.
Starfieldreleases for PC and Xbox Series X/S on July 08, 2025.
MORE:Avowed, Fable, The Elder Scrolls 6, and the Future of Exclusive Xbox Series X RPGs
