Though the MMO genre isn’t known for its ability to tell a compelling narrative, there are a few exceptional titles that break the mold. AsFinal Fantasy 14: A Realm Reborntells a grand tale that spans the diverse, luscious land of Eorzea, andWorld of Warcraftintroduced players to the wonderful world of Azeroth almost a decade prior. Since the release ofFinal Fantasy 14:A Realm Rebornin the summer of 2013, the two titans of the Massive Multiplayer Online space have frequently been the subject of detailed comparisons.
While similarities are apparent in their approach to the social side of the genre, the high-fantasy setting, andplentiful support since their respective releases with hefty expansions,Final Fantasy 14andWorld of Warcraftare largely different in the way they each approach the subject of storytelling. Each are ripe for epic, satisfying tales to unfold, yet SquareEnix and Blizzard Entertainment have different philosophies in regard to the roll-out of such stories, which makes each worthy of experiencing.
RELATED:Warcraft Franchise is Getting ‘Substantial’ New Content in 2022
Azeroth and Eorzea Each Have A Story Worth Telling
The most fundamental difference between howWorld of Warcraft,andFinal Fantasy 14handle their respective stories is within the game design itself.World of Warcraft’s setting, tone, and combat are at the heart of its narrative experience, as the plot is often minimal apart from some significant lore. As such, the story pushes forward (with a few exceptions) with far less core storytelling thanFinal Fantasy 14. However, the weight behindWorld of Warcraft’s name would have players believe the story is a lost cause if it wasn’t undertaken all those years ago, but this isn’t the case. Thanks to its often simplistic writing,exploring theWorld of Warcrafttale from the beginningisn’t the impossible feat many would think.
Conversely,Final Fantasy 14is a game that revels in its intricate character development, convoluted story arcs, and deliberate narrative pacing. From the humble dwelling of Gridania to the towering spires of Ishgard, the quest that falls upon the Warrior of Light is littered with lengthy cutscenes and stellar character interactions. This is a main-line entry in the esteemedFinal Fantasyseries, and though the blunder ofFinal Fantasy 11seemingly rendered the franchise unsuitable for the MMO genre, the approach to shared worlds this time around was far more refined. The improvements extended to storytelling, asFinal Fantasy 14succeeds where its predecessors also triumphed, with its tale being one of sacrifice, heroism, companionship, and bravery.
A Story Is Only As Good As Its Characters
To tell a memorable story, the people that inhabit it have to be memorable, too. WhileWorld of Warcraft’s playable races will be recognizable to those who are familiar withDungeons and Dragons, the offerings available inFinal Fantasy 14are far more unique to the experience. With a number assigned comes expectations, one of which is quality character development.Final Fantasy,despite surviving in a somewhat crowded JRPG genre, has always been unique to itself. As such, opting to includeLalafell rather than Gnomesor Roegadyn instead of Orcs gives some much-needed distance betweenFinal Fantasy 14and itsWorld of Warcraftcounterpart.
Some characters in theever-improvingWorld of Warcraftuniversehave been there since the 2004 beginning, and as players have grown over the course of its 18-year life, it’s increasingly easier to forget the flaws of the game’s approach to character development.Final Fantasy 14doesn’t have as much of a history, so it’s easy for the characters that line the lands of Eorzea to fade into the background of the series.
RELATED:What a Warcraft Mobile Game Could Look Like
World of Warcraft and Final Fantasy 14’s Opposite Upbringings
Final Fantasy 14has a legacy to protect - one that’s steeped in wonderful single-player storytelling. From Locke to Noctis, the series has a lineage of over 30 years that has placed far more emphasis on narrative pacing and writing than social connectivity.Final Fantasy 14’s community has long been considered one of the best in the MMO genre, but as most players spend their time dipping in and out of cutscenes, there’s rarely any opportunity for toxicity. Though its proficiency in handling core MMO mechanics is evident,Final Fantasy 14feels like a singleplayer experience first and foremost, with the community and party aspects fitting around the solo offerings.
World of Warcraft’s origins lie in the MMO genre, and the importance of the story often feels overshadowed by other, equally important components. A streamlined combat system, interesting PvP, and superb,ever-improving dungeonsare as important toWorld of Warcraftas a compelling story, which is a design philosophy that most Massive Multiplayer Online games adhere to. WhereFinal Fantasy 14,andWorld of Warcraftdiffer is their beginnings, which have gone on the shape the way in which each carries its narrative forward.
Comparisons Are Temporary, Great Stories Are Everlasting
The impressive tales that make up much ofFinal Fantasy 14’s content are undoubtedly the main draw to the game,as is the way with anyFinal Fantasyrelease.World of Warcraftis different, instead placing more emphasis on the lore of the world and taking its time allowing for the narrative to unfold. Expansions have developed theWorld of Warcraftstory, though each of the eight expansions seems to inch the game further away from the fundamentals that made it so great to begin with.Final Fantasy 14has only four expansions, and despite all offering exceptional storytelling, they require the player’s undivided attention, so completing the often mechanically uninspired quests is not something that can be done passively.
BothWorld of WarcraftandFinal Fantasy 14have a seat atop the MMO mountain, and players will continue to flock to their servers for years to come thanks to the quirks that makes each so special. The similarities are evident, and thecompetition between the two is irritatingly fierce at times, but the genre is made better by their critical differences. Stories have the potential to unfold in any number of unique ways, andWorld of WarcraftandFinal Fantasy 14both succeed in bringing theirs to life.
